Paula Abdul chose "Dance, Little Sister" for Danny Gokey, but while his singing received good reviews, Kara DioGuardi wasn't a fan of Gokey's moves. He chose "You Are So Beautiful" as his second song, which the judges raved about. Kara told him, "Everything you didn't do [in your first song], you just did!" Twitterers had mixed reviews of his performances:
RyanOConnor Still LOVES Danny Gokey and doesn't care if it's not as cool as it used to be!! I'm loyal, if nothing else!! nerfwarriors I think Danny Gokey might be the most boring singer EVER... theburglar1337 really really likes Danny Gokey, despite being brainwashed by all of the Adam and Chris zombies. rochelle71 American Idol show was great tonight. Been voting for Danny Gokey. Hope he's in the finale. le_ponch Dear America, please send Danny Gokey home. Sincerely ME
Kris Allen had a strong night on the show, first singing the Randy and Kara chosen "Apologize" and then putting his own spin on Kanye West's hit "Heartless". While Kara said he didn't "hit it out of the park," tweets from "Idol" fans were overwhelmingly positive:
markasey Kris Allen just may be the cutest guy I've ever seen. shoelover14 my american idol is kris allen :) natetang I though that Kris Allen did a great job with the Kayne West song tonight. http://bit.ly/Hofvy - It is going to be close on American Idol etazar01 Just voted for Kris Allen like a zillion times... My finger is tired:( nashae loved Kris Allen's performance. lolz@ Simon, he's funny.
Simon Cowell chose Adam Lambert's first song, "One" by U2. The judges all agreed it was another strong performance, and were equally enthusiastic about his rendition of Aerosmith's "Cryin." Simon encouraged everyone to vote for Lambert, and while some proclaimed their fandom over Twitter, others in the Twitterverse weren't thrilled with his songs:
GodivaFilm @ttaumua Adam Lambert is NOT going home until next week- when he has won^^ sasigurl430 I always have a big smile on my face throughout each and everyone of Adam Lambert's performances :D. ashposh Adam Lambert is totally going to win this competition! He has new and interesting stuff every week and, although I like Danny, he's amazing! kaytiebeth06 I'm still pissed alison isn't on american idol, but i do love me some adam lambert. sbgaines Is Adam Lambert *trying* to lose to get out of an Idol contract?! Did he just BLOW the surest Idol lead ever? walrusoct9 I had the accidental misfortune of hearing Adam Lambert sing U2's "One." Why couldn't I have been born deaf? My ears may never recover.
Post-"Idol" tweets about Lambert weren't solely about his singing talent - Twitterers were also gossiping about recent reports that Adam could be the first gay "American Idol." Lambert appears alone on the May 15 cover of Entertainment Weekly with the headline "Most Exciting 'American Idol' Contestant In Years," but most Twitter users seem to think that Lambert's sexuality is no big deal and are expressing support for the rocker:
mosbold Boy, Adam Lambert. You reppin' the gay community big time. Damn, you can sing. dannydefreitas Will Adam Lambert be the first gay American Idol? (i'm thinking.... HELLZ YEAHHH!!! BrendanPMurphy If Adam Lambert wins America will have voted for a Black President and a Gay Rock Star in the same year. Great stuff U.S! stay open-minded.. leyyyy someone told me adam lambert is gay? danggggg it. no hope for me :( ernestsewell Does it matter if Adam Lambert is gay or not? Is he "hiding" if he doesn't COME OUT? His friends/family know, so who is he hiding from?
Check back with Breaking Tweets Entertainment for a follow-up on Wednesday's elimination show!